Timeless Christmas

As the holiday season approaches, our quest for the perfect festive libation intensifies. While lighter, effervescent drinks like champagne and vodka-based cocktails have graced our gatherings in the past, this year, we yearned for something with more depth, character, and a touch of smoky sophistication. What better way to fulfill that desire than with a splendid whiskey-based creation?

The classic Old Fashioned, with its elegant simplicity and robust flavor profile, provided the perfect canvas for our holiday inspiration. Having perfected delightful twists like the Apple Old Fashioned and the Peach Old Fashioned, it felt only natural to craft a version that celebrates the magic of Christmas.

Our unique holiday rendition replaces the traditional sugar cube with a delightful pine syrup, introducing an unexpected yet utterly harmonious forest-fresh note. A splash of vibrant cranberry juice cocktail adds a festive hue and a balanced tartness, creating a drink that truly embodies Christmas cheer. With just a handful of carefully selected ingredients and a classic lowball glass, you’re mere moments away from experiencing this extraordinary seasonal cocktail.

Please note: This post contains affiliate links, meaning we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you if you make a purchase through them. For more details, see our disclosure policy.

Why a Christmas Old Fashioned?

The Old Fashioned stands as a pillar of cocktail history, revered for its timeless appeal and ability to highlight the complex notes of fine whiskey. Its simplicity is its strength, allowing the core spirit to shine while bitters and a hint of sweetness provide structure and depth. For the holiday season, this foundation becomes an exciting opportunity for innovation, inviting festive ingredients to dance with the familiar warmth of whiskey.

A Christmas Old Fashioned offers a comforting counterpoint to the often bustling and bright holiday atmosphere. It’s a drink designed for slow sipping, for quiet evenings by the fire, or for intimate conversations during festive gatherings. The infusion of cranberry and pine transforms the drink into an aromatic experience, conjuring images of frosted forests and holiday feasts. It’s a sophisticated choice for those who appreciate a well-crafted cocktail and seek to elevate their holiday drinking experience beyond the usual.

The Heart of the Holiday Spirit: Key Ingredients

Crafting the perfect Christmas Old Fashioned relies on a few high-quality, thoughtfully chosen ingredients. Each component plays a crucial role in building the layered flavors that make this cocktail so special.

• Whiskey – The soul of any Old Fashioned. Traditionally, rye whiskey is favored for its spicy, assertive character, which beautifully cuts through sweetness and complements the other seasonal flavors. We recommend a good quality rye for this recipe to truly bring out its depth. However, if you prefer a smoother, slightly sweeter profile, a high-quality bourbon would also make an excellent choice, adding notes of caramel and vanilla. Consider exploring our curated list of the best whiskeys for an Old Fashioned to find your perfect pour.
• Cranberry Juice Cocktail – This vibrant addition introduces a delightful tartness and a beautiful ruby hue, instantly evoking the holiday spirit. We specify “cranberry juice cocktail” as it typically contains a degree of sweetness, providing balance to the drink. If you opt for unsweetened 100% cranberry juice, we suggest adding a touch of simple syrup (about 1/4 to 1/2 oz, or to taste) to ensure your cocktail isn’t overly tart.
• Pine Syrup – This is where the Christmas magic truly happens! Replacing the traditional sugar cube or simple syrup, pine syrup infuses the cocktail with a unique, earthy, and subtly resinous aroma that is unmistakably festive. It’s a flavor profile that transports you straight to a winter forest. You can purchase excellent pine syrups, such as the Maine pine syrup we used, or even try your hand at making your own for an extra personal touch. If making your own, ensure you use edible pine species (like white pine or spruce tips) and consult reliable foraging guides.
• Bitters – An indispensable ingredient in any Old Fashioned, bitters add aromatic complexity and help to tie all the flavors together. For this Christmas variation, we found that orange bitters perfectly complement the cranberry and pine, adding bright, citrusy notes. However, feel free to experiment with other types like Angostura bitters for a more classic, spiced undertone, or even a dash of black walnut bitters for an extra layer of nutty depth.

Crafting Your Festive Old Fashioned: Step-by-Step Instructions

Making a Christmas Old Fashioned is a simple yet rewarding process, designed to be enjoyed as much in the making as in the sipping. Follow these easy steps to create your perfect holiday cocktail:

1. Prepare Your Glass: Start by selecting a sturdy lowball or Old Fashioned glass. Add 1 ounce of pine syrup, 2 dashes of your chosen bitters (orange bitters work wonderfully here), and 1 ounce of cranberry juice cocktail to the glass.
2. Muddle and Mix: Give these ingredients a gentle stir with a bar spoon. This ensures the syrup, bitters, and juice are well combined and create a harmonious base before introducing the whiskey. This initial mix is crucial for a balanced flavor from the first sip.
3. Add Ice: Carefully place a large block or sphere of ice into the glass. The larger surface area of big ice melts slower, ensuring your drink stays perfectly chilled without becoming diluted too quickly.
4. Pour the Whiskey: Measure out 2 ounces of your preferred whiskey (rye or bourbon) and slowly pour it over the ice. The gradual pour allows the whiskey to settle and integrate with the other ingredients.
5. Final Stir and Chill: Give the cocktail another gentle stir for about 15-30 seconds. This step is vital for chilling the whiskey to the optimal temperature, further blending the flavors, and achieving the perfect balance.
6. Garnish and Enjoy: Add your desired garnish (see tips below for ideas) and savor the rich, festive aromas and flavors of your homemade Christmas Old Fashioned!

Expert Tips for a Perfect Pour

Elevate your Christmas Old Fashioned from good to exceptional with these seasoned bartender tips:

1. The Importance of Quality Ice: As mentioned in the instructions, ice is not just for chilling; it’s an ingredient. Small, standard ice cubes melt rapidly, leading to a watered-down drink. A large block or sphere of ice provides sustained chilling with minimal dilution, preserving the integrity of your cocktail’s flavor. You can easily make your own pristine block ice at home using inexpensive silicone molds, ensuring crystal-clear ice that melts slowly and evenly.
2. Creative Garnishes: The garnish is the finishing touch, adding visual appeal and enhancing the aromatic experience. We love using a small clipping from a fresh Christmas tree (ensure it’s clean and chemical-free!) and a preserved pine bud for an authentic, woodsy feel. Other fantastic options include fresh cranberries, a sprig of fragrant rosemary, a twisted orange peel, or even a cinnamon stick for a spicy aroma. Choose a garnish that complements the seasonal theme and the drink’s flavors.
3. Big Batch for Holiday Gatherings: Hosting a party? Save yourself time and stress by preparing a large batch of this cocktail in advance. Simply multiply the ingredient amounts below by the number of cocktails you plan to serve. Mix all ingredients (excluding ice) in a large pitcher or jar. We find a 32oz mason jar works perfectly for storage. Keep it chilled in the refrigerator until it’s time to pour. When serving, just add a large piece of ice to each lowball glass and pour in the pre-batched mixture. This ensures every guest enjoys a perfectly balanced cocktail without you playing bartender all night.
4. Pre-Chill Your Glassware: For an extra touch of sophistication and to keep your cocktail colder for longer, pre-chill your lowball glasses in the freezer for at least 15-20 minutes before serving.
5. Adjust Sweetness to Taste: The amount of pine syrup suggested is a starting point. Feel free to adjust it based on your personal preference for sweetness and the specific type of cranberry juice you’re using. You can always add a little more, but you can’t take it away!

Beyond the Glass: Pairing and Occasions

The Christmas Old Fashioned is versatile enough to be enjoyed on various occasions throughout the holiday season. Its robust and complex flavor profile makes it an excellent choice for:

• Fireside Sipping: There’s nothing quite like unwinding by a crackling fire with a comforting, warm drink. This cocktail fits the bill perfectly, offering a sense of coziness and peace.
• Holiday Dinner Parties: Serve it as a sophisticated aperitif before a lavish Christmas dinner or as a digestif after the meal. Its complex flavors can stand up to rich holiday fare.
• Gift Wrapping Sessions: Make the task of wrapping presents a little more enjoyable with a festive drink in hand.
• Winter Evenings: Even without a special occasion, this cocktail is ideal for any chilly winter evening when you crave something deeply flavorful and warming.

When it comes to food pairings, consider:

• Cheese Boards: Hard, aged cheeses like cheddar or gouda, and even some blues, pair beautifully with whiskey cocktails.
• Dark Chocolate Desserts: The richness of dark chocolate or chocolate-based desserts will find a delightful companion in the notes of whiskey and pine.
• Roasted Nuts: A simple bowl of spiced or candied nuts can be a wonderful accompaniment.
• Hearty Appetizers: Small bites featuring smoked meats or earthy mushrooms would also complement this drink well.

Explore More Festive Drinks

If you’re looking to expand your holiday cocktail repertoire, we have a variety of other festive recipes that are sure to delight your guests:

• Cranberry Moscow Mule
• Christmas Punch in a Can
• Christmas Champagne Cocktail
• Christmas Cranberry Sorbet Mimosa