The Old Fashioned stands as a true testament to the timeless appeal of classic cocktails. Simple yet sophisticated, it combines whiskey, sugar, and bitters to create a drink where the spirit itself takes center stage. This beautiful simplicity means that your choice of whiskey isn’t just important—it’s absolutely critical. The right whiskey elevates an Old Fashioned from a mere drink to an exquisite experience, while the wrong one can easily diminish its potential.
Navigating the vast world of whiskeys to find the perfect match for this iconic cocktail can be a daunting task. That’s why we’ve undertaken the enjoyable but extensive research for you, meticulously tasting and evaluating dozens of different whiskeys specifically within the context of an Old Fashioned. Our goal was to identify those exceptional bottles that truly shine, enhancing the drink’s inherent character rather than overshadowing it.
Below, we’ve compiled a curated list of our absolute favorite whiskeys, meticulously selected to ensure your Old Fashioned is nothing short of spectacular. Whether you’re crafting a traditional version or experimenting with a seasonal twist like an apple old fashioned, a peach old fashioned, or even our festive Christmas old fashioned recipe, these whiskeys promise to deliver an unparalleled drinking experience.
